It's been nothing short of a whirlwind existence for the XFL, originally designed to be the perfect mix of WWE drama, with the live action of professional level football, the league ultimately lasted just one season that started with a bang before viewership trailed off and the WWE as well as partner NBC both lost around $35 million in the first season. This loss prompted NBC to back out, however the WWE had the resources to continue supporting the league before reports of nearly impossible demands from one of the networks that broadcast their games made it a challenge to find avenues to bring in a larger crowd. Ultimately the league ceased operations shortly after their championship game.
The original league had 8 teams, and 2 divisions with this list of teams;
Eastern Division:
Birmingham Thunderbolts
Chicago Enforcers
New York/New Jersey Hitmen
Orlando Rage
Western Division:
Las Vegas Outlaws
Los Angeles Xtreme
Memphis Maniacs
San Francisco Demons
I'm honestly surprised that the XFL never caught on back then. There were some NFL caliber players on those rosters, guys who went on to play in or win Grey Cups, and/or Super Bowls. In fact 21 different players appeared in Bowl games in the NFL and CFL combined. 7 players won Super Bowls, 4 won both Super Bowls and an XFL championship game. One man even won an XFL championship, a grey cup, and a super bowl. Talk about an impressive career. If you look at players that went on to play in the NFL, CFL, and AFL the numbers are huge considering this league was alive for just one disappointing season. This league was viewed more as a side show than main attraction with the gimmicks from the WWE clearly visible and ultimately not a draw for modern NFL fans.
Fast forward 17 years and Vince McMahon reestablished the XFL,bringing it back for another try at professional football. However this time he did it on his own without partners immediately making bold claims that he had bankrolled two seasons regardless of performance. Well little did McMahon know the world would be suffering from a pandemic that caused every sports league even the largest of them stop dead in their tracks. It ultimately resulted in the straw that broke the camel's back with the AFL, the only viable American alternative to the NFL, and eventually the XFL succumbed to the pressure of funding a league that didnt know when it would be allowed to see the field again.
The sad part is this time around the XFL had a real following, and was being taken very seriously. In fact there were rumblings that players from college could eventually use the XFL as a springboard to the NFL draft. This was a rather unheard of concept, however, 6'2 200 lb Kenny Robinson a safety who started 5 games for the XFL was able to then apply for NFL draft consideration. Ultimately he was drafted by Carolina in the 5th round but his future in the NFL could pave the way for more players. It's actually incredibly impressive the amount of players that were signed to contracts with the NFL right away.
QB Pj Walker signed with Carolina to compete with Will Grier to be Teddy Bridgewater's backup. Not a bad spot to be in considering he couldn't crack the Colts as a third string qb just a year ago.
QB Jordan Ta'amu decided latching on with Andy Reid and company was his best bet for success. I would argue he was right. I expect him to be their third qb in 2020.
TE Donald Parham signed with the Chargers a team that suffered from depth concerns last season. Walking into 2020 he might be the third tight with a chance at unseating solid but never spectacular Virgil Green as the number 2.
RB Jaques Patrick signed with Cincy to compete for a roster spot although I dont like his chances of cracking the 53 man roster.
WR De'Mornay Pierson is a guy who decided sticking with a team you know even if they cut you once was the way to go, and I would argue he was right.
WR Saeed Blacknall is a player I thought would get a better shot at making a roster, however he signed with Pittsburgh to compete for a roster spot with about 5 other more established receivers.
TE Khari Lee is a blocking specialist who signed with Atlanta a team that watched Austin Hooper leave via free agency while replacing him with Hayden Hurst an unproven first round pick of Baltimore that didnt pan out mostly due to the emergence of Mark Andrew's.
TE Colin Thompson is a potential third tight end for Carolina that is a versatile player. Known for his blocking he is also an asset on special teams and could make the roster because of those two things alone.
DB Dravon Askew Henry is a guy I truly believe could make the active roster for the Giants in 2020. Due to the lack of quality depth in front of him after several high draft picks so far not working out for the team in Eli Apple, Sam Beal, and now DeAndre Baker. He is a safety by trade but at 6'0 200 lbs and running a 4.52 40, he could easily be used inside as a nickel back, or as a safety still. Jalen Mills comes to mind as a comparison.
LB Demarquis Gates is a former Houston Roughneck as well. He will be the backup to Anthony Barr who has played just two 16 game seasons in 6 seasons with Minnesota. I believe he is in the perfect situation to make the roster.
The Steelers have several players with a chance to make their active roster first of all there is defensive lineman Cavon Walker who is listed as a defensive tackle in Pittsburgh's depth chart but truly will play defensive end in a 3-4 base defense. He currently sits in a 3 way competition for the 4th defensive end spot. At 6'2 278 lbs he can play end in a 3-4 alignment or inside at tackle in a 4-3 front. He has solid speed for a bigger lineman which should help his chances.
CB Breon Borders was originally signed by the Steelers after the XFL folded, however he was signed off waivers by Miami. The Dolphins might give him a better chance at making the roster as it stands. They have less established depth players with maybe 4 players a lock to make the roster.
WR Saeed Blacknall is buried on the depth chart behind Juju Smith-Schuster, James Washington, Diontae Johnson, Deon Cain, Chase Claypool, Ryan Switzer. Then he has to compete with Amara Darboh and Anthony Johnson for what might turn out to only be a practice squad spot.
I also noticed a trend among the Steeler's XFL signings, they valued in game experience on the offensive line signing not 1, not 2, but 3 offensive lineman from the league.
Center John Keenoy, didn't start in the XFL until week 4, with the league canceling the rest of the season after week 5,so it's hard to say how much this playing time helped him get back in the NFL but the thing is that playing time from an offensive line man's perspective can never hurt.
OL Anthony Coyle might have solidified a job for himself somewhere simply based on his versatility. In college he spent all his time at tackle. Starting on the right side before playing the majority of his college career at left tackle. He then signed with several NFL practice squad from 2018-2020 when he joined the XFL. In the XFL the Guardians asked him to play guard, Coyle obliged simply adding another job to his resume as a depth lineman. The thing with offensive line depth is the more positions you can play the more likely you are to make a roster and be active on game day.
Tackle Jarron Jones helped his case by playing in the XFL the most. He has bounced between offense and defense several times now. The XFL saw him get in game reps at tackle against professional level competition.
I could keep going on and on about the players who have already made the move to the NFL, however none of this affects the XFL assuming they stick to their plan of a spring league. In fact if former NFL player Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson is smart he will start negotiating with the NFL to release its bottom of the roster and practice squad players to his league in an effort to aid their development. Also with the CFL and AFL both shutting down in 2020 there is suddenly a large talent pool to tap for XFL or fringe NFL level talent.
Suddenly there are viable replacements for players lost to the NFL. Quarterbacks with professional experience are now available left and right. Look at this list of names seeking employment:
Bo Levi Mitchell-Calgary Stampeders- Mitchell is one of the most decorated qbs in the CFL. He has 8 seasons under his belt displaying durability with just one major injury. He completed 64.8% of his passes despite mass injuries at receiver at times, with 27,937 passing yards 169 tds, and just 70 ints he displays football IQ and a propensity to protect the ball without sacrificing the deep ball. He also added 148 carries for 727 yards or 4.6 per carry with 14 rushing tds. What's more impressive is his insane win loss record. 77-16-1. No other CFL qb has ever done won as many games as fast as Mitchell has. This time last offseason he was trying out for 5 NFL teams, and 5 other teams were interested. He wound up turning down offers to be a backup in order to go back and start in the CFL. With the CFL shuttered it is entirely possible he changes his mind and signs on to be a backup qb somewhere, but if his desire to play is still alive the XFL would be his best option. With the XFL losing a few of its star players from their 2020 season this would be a way to bring in a starting qb with pro experience who could help draw the CFL audience to the XFL during their shut down. He has won 2 grey cups, and 3 MVP awards in his career. Mitchell is getting older but at 30 years old still has many years of football left in him and has a better chance at making the jump to the NFL than our next qb on the list due to his relative youth.
Another qb Mike Reilly might be another plausible option. Reilly has been in the CFL since 2010 after spending one year trying to make NFL rosters and winding up released by the Steelers, Packers, Rams, and Seahawks. This led him to sign a practice squad contract with the BC Lions. He only spent 1 month on the practice squad before moving up to the active roster as the 3rd string qb. He won his first grey cup win as the 3red string qb in 2011 before he got his first start in October of 2012 however he was never really the unquestioned starter in BC. He was then traded to the Edmonton Eskimos. This trade displayed how much the team believed in him because they agreed to exchange second round picks, and give up their second round pick the following year to obtain his rights. His first season as a starter with Edmonton he managed 4,207 passing yards, 709 rushing yards, 24 tds and 18 ints. For his career Reilly has 31,522 yards, 168 tds and 99 ints while adding 637 carries for 3,366 yards and 52 tds. Reilly is 35 years old but for the XFL age isn't as important as it is to the NFL which could push him to sign with the XFL over any backup job that might come his way with the NFL. We have seen several qbs play into their 40's in the NFL but it's not very often in the modern NFL that guys play 9 years in the CFL first. He would add an exciting player to watch to the St. Louis Battlehawks or Houston Roughnecks that lost their league leading qbs to the NFL.
Adam Bighill a LB for the Blue Bombers is a guy who likely should already be in the NFL, however due to his height 5'11 he was left on the scrap heap after the draft. He immediately turned to the CFL signing with the BC Lions. As a rookie they saw his abilities and started working him into the line up slowly, while also becoming a special teams star racking up 22 tackles. His next 4 seasons he continued to play special teams and defense racking up 47 special teams tackles to go with 374 defensive tackles, 28 sacks, 7 ints, 1 td, 8 forced fumbles. He decided after 2016 with his extensive resume he would make the leap to the NFL. He signed with the Saints where he spent a full seasons bouncing between the active roster and the practice squad never logging a stat. In May of 2018 he requested his release after realizing he wasn't getting a fair shake on a team that desperately needed better play at LB. He returned to the CFL this time with the Winnipeg Blue Bombers. Originally signing a 1 year deal they offered him a 3 year extension the following year. He has played in 9 CFL seasons, and 1 NFL season so far. During that time he was Grey Cup Champion twice, named most outstanding defensive player twice, 5 times voted to the allstar team, and voted to the west conference's allstar team 6 times. He is 31 years old but has shown no signs of slowing down. This is the kind of player who would be a force in the XFL, and a guy who can rush the passer, play the passing game, and create turnovers often. His age is prohibitive to an NFL contract at this point but the XFL would welcome him with open arms.
Micah Johnson a DT from BC could be on the radar of the NFL after they lost a bunch of defensive linemen to opt outside, and injuries already. He spent 4 seasons bouncing around in the NFL from 2010-2013 never on an active roster before signing with the CFL's Calgary Stampeders where he spent 2013-2018. The 6'2 278 lb defensive tackle is more of a pass rusher than a run stopper but has displayed a knack for getting to qbs. Despite starting his career as a backup he now has 184 tackles, 45 sacks, and 2 ints from the 2013 season to 2019 from a DEFENSIVE TACKLE position. That's unheard of. This guy averaged just under 7 sacks a season even though he didnt take a starting role until 2015. He is 32 years old and past the point of signing with the NFL again, but a stint with the XFL makes plenty of sense.
Andrew Harris might be more of a stretch as a 33 year old running back with 11 seasons of wear and tear on his 5'10 202 lb frame...until you consider this man has racked up 14,145 yards, and 79 tds just on offense. He also adds value in the return game and on special teams in other roles. I like Harris's story because he is a Canadian National that played 3 years in their development league leading his team to 3 straight championships. He then went on to the CFL and helped win two more championships his latest last year in 2019 when he was named Grey Cup MVP. This guy has done it all in the CFL. He has completed 2 of 6 passes for 21 yards, rushed 1,673 times for 9,038 yards, 5.4 yards per carry, and 46 tds, he has displayed remarkable skills as a receiver with 565 receptions for 5,107 yards, and 30 tds, 37 punt returns for 374 yards, 47 kick returns for 902 yards, 21 tackles, 7 on special teams, 11 fumbles, 1 recovery, and 1 forced fumble. This man is nothing short of a legend in Canada having grown into one of the league's biggest stars after starting off in the Juniors system. He has played his entire career in Canada, but with them not suiting up this season will he give American league play a chance? The XFL would love to have a guy with his resume, and fan base to further extend their influence in other markets while also simply wanting the most electric players they can get.
Delvin Breaux is a guy I am almost certain will go on to play in the XFL. This guy has laid everything on the line to play football. After breaking 3 vertebrae while making a tackle on a kick return in high school, his future changed forever. This guy had a scholarship to LSU prior to the injury, a dream come true for a kid who was born and raised in New Orleans. Alas he never suited up for the Tigers because their doctors refused to clear him for play. He would serve as a player coach before deciding it wasn't over as a player and moving on. He fell off the map for a couple years before coming back healthy with the Louisiana Bayou Vipers of the Gridiron Developmental League where he dominated, and wound up moving on to the next level. Signing a deal with the New Orleans Voodoo of the Arena Football League. After his single season here he decided to move on to the CFL. Three seasons, three different leagues. He played two seasons with the Hamilton Tigercats. He racked up 62 tackles, 3 forced fumbles, 1 recovery, 1 int for 27 yards and a td, and 1 sack. This was enough to catch the eye of the Saints his hometown NFL team. His first year with the Saints he looked like a shut down corner. 41 tackles, 19 pass break ups, 1 fumble recovery and 3 ints. At this point the story couldn't be any more ripe for a documentary. New Orleans kid recovers from broken back to become starter for Saints...but in 2016 it fell apart. The first game of the year Breaux broke his fibula and missed 6 weeks, he returned to play 7 games before suffering a shoulder injury that sent him to IR. He returned to the team in 2017, but in August of 2017 suffered a fractured fibula, that was misdiagnosed by two separate team doctors. After not making any progress in his rehab they xrayed him again and found the break. Both doctors were fired but too little too late Breaux would go on to miss the 2017 season and ultimately fall out of the NFL. Ultimately he signed a deal with the Tiger Cats to return becoming the highest paid DB in the league. He went on to play in 2018, and 2019 for them with 50 tackles, 2 pass break ups, 4 fumble recoveries for 73 yards and 1 td, as well as 3 forced fumbles, and 1 int for 4 yards. It remains to be seen what his next move is but after a story popped up the day following the CFL shut down Breaux said he has nothing left financially and has been struggling in recent years. Which leads me to believe he will try and latch on with the NFL or CFL wherever he can land a contract to help alleviate his woes. However he better start making better decisions financially because the 31 year old DB with an extensive major injury history will not be on any league's radar for too many more seasons.
Last but not least from the CFL players is QB Jeremiah Massoli. This name might ring some bells for college football fans. Massoli became the starting qb for the Oregon Ducks after climbing his way up the depth chart from 3rd string having transferred from a junior college. However in 2010 a string of run ins with the law led to him leaving Oregon. He sent out scholarship release paperwork to 5 schools before ultimately deciding on Ole Miss. However his waiver for immediate play was denied. He decided to appeal and won the appeal but it put him in the unenviable position of starting week 3 for Ole Miss with very little time to adapt to his new offense. He ultimately had a down year which likely led to him going undrafted. As we all know the NFL will look past legal issues if the player demonstrates the ability to play well. Massoli didnt manage that his last season. However he signed with San Francisco as an undrafted free agent in 2011. They ultimately released him which allowed him to be eligible for the 2011 UFL draft. He was selected by the Omaha Nighthawks. Looking at his stats through his first four season compared to his last 4 seasons it's clear he needed to develop as a passer. Through his first 4 years in the pros: he never stopped a 54% completion rate, threw for just 1,261 yards, 5 tds to 8 ints adding 239 rushing yards and 2 td. It wasnt until his 5th season, 4th with the Tiger cats that he started to play well. He started in 2016 completing 69.9% of his passes but managed just 15 tds to 12 ints.the following three seasons saw him improve on his int numbers. 52 tds to 30 ints, never falling below a 63.7% completion rate or 8.0 yards per attempt. He also added 1,179 rushing yards, and 14 tds during this stretch. All of a sudden he looks like a viable starting qb. Masoli turns 31 years old next week and is coming a torn ACL, with the CFL shuttered in 2020, and his age/injury status right now the XFL is his best bet to play and start in another league.
From Arena Football:
Grant Russell was a rookie in 2019 completing 183 of 300 for 2,132 yards 36 tds, 14 ints, while ranking 4th in the league in rushing with 30 Carrie's for 75 yards and 4tds. This guy is young and was a four year starter that put up solid numbers in college. He's mobile, which is a plus in the XFL. He is also hungry, after the AFL folded he went on to the National Arena League. He would welcome a shot in the XFL right now. They just need to give him a call.
WR Fabian Guerra was also a rookie in 2019, as far as the AFL was concerned. He started at WR, while contributing in the run game and return game. He caught 61 passes for 765 yards, 15 tds, 8 carries 20 yards, and 2 tds, 39 kick returns, 736 yards, and 3 tds and 3 tackles. He is the perfect guy for the XFL to target. This guy however is only 25 having spent 2018 in the National Arena League with the Carolina Cobras, 2019 was split between the Memphis Express of the Aliance of American Football, the Columbus Destroyers of the AFL, and another stint with the Carolina Cobras. This man just wants to play. He was named the AFL co rookie of the year in 2019, and parlayed that into a CFL contract for 2020...until they too shuttered for 2020 This poor guy went through the AAF, and AFL completely folding in one season, then was hit with the CFL shuttering in 2020. He would jump for a joy at a chance at the XFL for their next season.
WR Milton William's is a 6'3 210lb player who ran 4.69 but runs faster in game than that would suggest. Last season, his 3rd in the AFL he caught 59 passes for 665 yards and recorded 11 tds for the second season in a row. He also had 7 tackles in 2019. He had a brief stint with the Oakland Raiders in 2015 but it didnt last long by 2017 he was playing with the Baltimore Brigade of the AFL where he spent all 3 of his years in the league. No news has come out on him signing with another league for 2020. XFL needs this guy.
DB/LB Joe Powell is another journeyman player who has signed anywhere and everywhere to keep his dreams alive. His run in football has been nothing short of nomadic:
2015-Lehigh Valley Steelhawks of the PIFL
2016-Cleveland Gladiators of the AFL, attends rookie mini camp with Philadelphia Eagles, before signing with the New York Giants for a cup of tea in training camp. He signed with the Bills practice squad in October and spent the rest of the year there, going on to sign a reserve futures deal to join the team for the 2017 training camp.
2017-Buffalo Bills NFL, cut in September out of football.
2018-Atlanta Havoc of the American Arena League, by March he was assigned to the Baltimore Brigade of the AFL.
2019-Birmingham Iron of the AAF until the league folded, and he was assigned to the Brigade for a second stint.
2020-St. Louis Battlehawks of the XFL drafted him and he went on to score the first special teams td in the league, after they shut down for 2020, he signed with the Hamilton Tiger Cats of the CFL which just announced its shut down for 2020.
Powell's best option to get back on the field asap is to resign with the XFL when they return. This guy is incredibly versatile and fits pro style defenses in a nickel LB role.
If the XFL is smart they hold a highly televised event where they reassign players to their previous XFL squads if they're available and interested, then hold a draft of the CFL, AFL, NFL, and college players that are forced to sit out the 2020 season, and form teams right away. Get the rosters compiled, get safety measures in place then start practicing by December. Give these squads several months of training camp til the spring 2021 season, in which you now have a huge influx of high level talent, with no competing leagues starting that early. But the key to this is ending the XFL season early enough that the college players can still participate in the 2021 NFL draft. You bring back the league for its third stint, pluck the cream of the crop of available players, then time the start up right in the dead spot between the Super bowl, and the draft. Boom. Perfect formula for a strong 2021 season that will build hype for 2022, and position you for further seasons if the cards are played right.