With 7 teams firing their head coaches, and several more replacing prominent personnel executives there is bound to be change especially at the league's most important position: Quarterback. If you're anything like I am a true football nerd the offseason when coaching changes, free agency and the draft occur is my favorite time of the year. Watching as franchises lay the building blocks for a dynasty, or make the mistakes that doom their tenure. Which is why this offseason has it all. You have a team in Houston potentially at a breaking point with their franchise qb with rumors of a blockbuster trade that we will touch on afoot, you have a team in the Colts that have their top 2 qbs both whom have started for them headed toward free agency on a roster built for success, you have a team in New England searching for an identity, a team in San Francisco whose starting qb was benched several times due to ineffectiveness, as well as controversies in Philadelphia, and potentially Dallas to sort out. It doesn't stop there either so let's dive right into the nitty gritty and start with the teams whose quarterbacks are headed toward free agency.
I will break this into 3 categories;
1.Starting level talent
2.Borderline starter/high level backups
3.backup level
In our first category the cream of the crop is none other than Dak Prescott.
1. Dak Prescott checks most of the boxes you could want in an impending free agent qb, he has had an ongoing valuation arguement with his team which leads one to believe he may actually wind up available. He is young and likely not at his ceiling developmentally, just 27 years old there is little doubt he will recover from his broken ankle and return to his probowl form in 2021. I still believe the Cowboys don't let him out of town but stranger things have happened.
2. Phillip Rivers is nearing age 40, a feat that has been conquered often by his contemporaries however Rivers is fresh off of a 1 year contract in which he lost a playoff game, which in itself wouldn't be enough to move on if it wasn't for his record of losing close games through out his career. Rivers is likely back in Indy unless they make a move for a young but established starter like Carson Wentz, Jimmy G, or DeShaun Watson. More on them later. Rivers has since announced his retirement although he retires as a free agent allowing him to sign a deal if he so chooses.
3. Mitchell Trubisky is headed toward free agency after the Bears declined his 5th year option. He is still just 26 years old with prototypical size at 6'2 220 lbs. In 51 games Trubisky has completed 64% of his passes throughout his career passing for 64 tds 37 ints, and 10,609 yards. Most likely didn't notice but he actually had one of his best statistical seasons in 2020. He had a qbr of 93.5 second highest of his career, 67% completion rate highest of his career, 6.9 yards per completion second highest of his career, he had over 41% 1st down rate highest of his career, despite the second least amount of passing attempts of his career he had just 1 less td than he managed in 2019 despite 219 more passing attempts. He also tossed the second least amount of ints in his career with 8. He isn't your typical dual threat qb but he has the mobility to run when needed with over 1,000 career rushing yards and 8 tds. I personally think the Patriots should consider looking at signing him if he makes it to free agency. In my eyes he is this year's Jameis Winston a guy who could still start immediately but might have to look into taking a 1 season backup role to rehab his image.
4. Jameis Winston was once a top overall pick so there is no doubt the physical tools are there the question with him is his decision making, accuracy and attitude. His last outing with the Saints resulting him being benched the following week for Sean Payton's man crush Taysom Hill. Winston was more a victim of circumstance here than anything. Hill knows this offense as well as anyone, Winston got an abbreviated offseason to learn an offense that was foreign to him then got put in a game relatively early in the season on a short leash. His stats in this one game are not even worth mentioning but this is still a young qb that threw for over 4,000 yards and 30 tds recently and could in the right system thrive.
5. Cam Newton struggled to learn the Josh McDaniels offense and it showed but you can't simply dismiss everything Newton is still physically capable of doing on a football field. To me this is more about fit than anything. He needs to find the right system, and in my eyes if he can't land a starting job the Ravens might want to consider bringing him in to replace RGIII who was let go.
6. Andy Dalton might be 34 years old in 2021 but he still played decently for a guy who was regarded as someone who might now be a career backup at this stage of his career. However in 2020 he played in 11 games passing for 2,160 yards 14 tds 8 ints completing 64% of his passes along the way. I could see him landing a job somewhere as a bridge qb, or staying in Dallas as their backup to Dak or bridge to their next qb.
7. Ryan Fitzpatrick is a guy who is as intelligent and experienced as they come but also as inconsistent and maddeningly terrible at times. Heading into his 17th season it seems to me he will have a job somewhere as long as he wants to play due to his ivy league intelligence and ability to learn any playbook quickly. He has started games for 8 teams in his career and it wouldn't surprise me to see him make it 9 in 2021. Perhaps he lands back in Miami as Tua's backup again. I would consider him the last legitimate potential starter of the free agent qbs.
Which brings me to the tier of borderline starters or high value backups.
8. Tyrod Taylor is extremely close to still being a starting level qb however there is still a large question as to how he will recover after a punctured lung, or how the league views him at this point after he spent the past 2 seasons as a backup for the Chargers. Personally I still think he could be a decent starter, but at this point his best options will be backup jobs. He likely could be another candidate to replace RGIII in Baltimore where he was originally drafted in the 5th round. His style of play is similar enough that they wouldn't need to alter their system if Lamar Jackson got hurt.
9. Jacoby Brissett is probably one of the best backup qbs in the league. He has experienced long stretches as a starter but never performed well enough to win the job outright but never performed poorly enough that his teammates or coaches lost faith in his ability to lead them to a victory. He has only taken a backseat to elite level quarterbacks in Tom Brady, Andrew Luck, and Phillip Rivers and that's for good reason, on any other team he would likely be challenging for a starting job. I am a huge fan of Brissett and I think his ideal landing spot is Denver. Drew Lock is still too young to replace with a draft pick but bringing in experienced competition, is a smart move and one they should absolutely make.
10. Joe Flacco is a long time starter at the point in his career where he is seen as past his prime and as a backup level qb at this point. He still has NFL level arm strength but I think he is past the point of throwing 70 yard bombs. This guy has played 13 years in the NFL and up until the last 3 seasons was the full time starter. He is extremely experienced and at this point best suited for a mentor role behind a young qb or as a short term bridge qb. He could wind up resigning in New York depending on how the cards fall with Sam Darnold.
11. Mike Glennon is headed toward free agency after he spent the 2020 season with the Jaguars bouncing in and out of the lineup. He had a rough year completing over 60% of his passes but throwing more ints than tds. In each of the last 5 seasons Glennon has suited up and played for a different team. During this stretch playing for the Buccaneers, Bears, Cardinals, Raiders, and Jaguars. I have a hunch he will be looking for team number 6 in 2021.
12. Geno Smith is now 30 years old, and has spent the last 2 seasons with the Seahawks as a backup to Russell Wilson who never gets hurt. He saw some action in garbage time in 2020 but didnt play at all in 2019. 2018 he was in San Diego as the backup to Phillip Rivers another guy who rarely misses time. His career is one of the most odd I have ever seen, he was a 2 year starter with the Jets his first two seasons playing in 30 games. Year 3 comes in 2015, the Jets had signed Ryan Fitzpatrick but expected him to be the backup until a LB punched Smith in the mouth effectively ending his career as a starter in one brutal punch that broke his jaw. Smith since that day has appeared in just 10 games. His stats were far from impressive as a starter and he is likely going to be a career backup at this point.
13. Colt McCoy is the definition of a journeyman but is a well liked guy who has continued to find backup jobs based on his athletic ability, experience and team first attitude. The former Texas Longhorn QB played for the Giants under Joe Judge in 2020 where he was asked to play in 4 games. He helped close out a win against Cincinnati and then went on to start against and beat the Seahawks outscoring Russell Wilson. He unfortunately went on to lose the following two games but showed enough to earn a contract extension with the Giants. After 11 years the 34 year old is aware of the fact that he is a backup at this point and has settled into that role being that his last major action was in his second season with the Browns who drafted him as a 3rd round pick.
14. Cj Beathard is heading into his 5th season, his previous 4 were spent under Kyle Shanahan one of the most respected offensive minds in the NFL. Over the 4 years it is clear he has developed although he has repeatedly been relegated to the backup role. In 2020 he was the beneficiary of Jimmy G and Nick Mullens suffering from injuries and inconsistent play. He would play in 6 games completing 63% of his passes for 7.6 yards per attempt both of which were career highs. He also had 6 tds and 0 ints proving his propensity to protect the football, which is the main area he has improved upon is his accuracy and decision making which I believe is the direct influence of Shanahan. In my eyes Beathard is an under rated backup candidate and could find himself in New York as a backup under his former coach Mike LaFluer assuming they don't bring back Flacco. He us still younger, and could potentially be a high upside backup having played in just 19 games.
Past this point you will find tier 3 or the now career backups with little upside.
15. Blaine Gabbert is now 31 years old, and was the backup to Tom Brady in 2020. He played in 4 games tossing 16 passes with 9 completions, for 143 yards 2 tds 0 ints. He is another journeyman QB that has developed into a solid backup qb but is not someone you want to count on for any prolonged stretch as a starter. He has had issues protecting the ball at times which is why he isn't higher on this list. In fact for his career he has 50 passing tds, 47 ints, fumbled 14 times, but added 3 rushing tds. He is nothing more than a short term answer on a team with an established starter.
16. Brian Hoyer has been around the block, playing in 70 games over a 12 season career with 6 different teams. He has started at times but typically as no more than a second option when needed. Hoyer at this point is 35 years old and on the back 9 of his career and likely not even at a point where most teams would consider him a number 2 option after watching the coach who knows him best relegating him to 3rd string behind Cam Newton, and Jarrett Stidham who both struggled.
17. Robert Griffin III was recently released by the Ravens but cannot sign with any playoff teams. He was ineffective in a couple appearances and the Ravens spent a draft pick on Trace McSorley who might be ready to take the number 2 role in 2021 if the Ravens don't look to Tyrod Taylor or Cam Newton instead. RGIII is a veteran who has seen the highest of highs an individual player can have by being named offensive rookie of the year to being out of the league for a year. He is still a valuable backup due to his athleticism but he is long past being a starter and might not find much interest this offseason.
18. Aj Mccaaron will be 31 years old in 2021, but has not appeared in more than 7 games his entire 6 year career. On several occasions he appeared in just 2 to 3 games. He has the required arm talent but due to his age, and poor decision making in his last several games and his lack of starting experience he will be spending the rest of his career trying to beat out younger draft picks for roster spots as a relatively low level backup qb. He could wind up staying in Houston but this entire offseason will prove to be out of the norm being that there is expected to be a dramatic drop in cap space.
19. Nate Sudfeld is a younger QB who was once upon a time a 7th round pick and practice squad player for the Redskins before the Eagles signed him off their practice squad and held on to him for the following 4 seasons. Sudfeld held onto the 3red string role for the Eagles for 2 years before Nick Foles was let go and Sudfeld was expected to be the top backup, instead he got injured and Josh McCown was signed to be the top backup. In 2020 Sudfeld was expected to finally be the top backup qb until the Eagles drafted a qb in the 2nd round, Hurts went on to claim the backup job and Sudfeld was relegated to 3rd string. People within the Eagles building have raced about Sudfeld saying he is a future starter but if that's the case why hasn't he been given the chance to even be the backup? In week 17 Pederson finally gave Sudfeld a chance to shine putting him in down by 3 against his former team. Sudfeld responded by going 5 for 12 for 32 yards 0 tds, 1 int. Not exactly the stat line you want right before free agency when you're a 27 year old 5th year veteran looking for a new job. I could see him being a target for the Jets, or Colts as a potential backup or 3rd string qbs.
20. Blake Bortles is a 7 year veteran and former first round pick who couldn't even manage to crack the lineup for the Broncos last season, who had Jeff Driskel as a backup prior to signing Bortles to the practice squad...ah yes the twilight zone that is 2020 where a 7 year veteran can be signed to the practice squad for the first time. He heads into the 2021 offseason a free agent having waited to sign a deal last offseason before settling on a practice squad spot. The sad part is Bortles is not a terrible qb, but he hasn't had a chance to prove himself since leaving Jacksonville and might never have that chance.
21. Matt Barkley, somehow the top backup to Josh Allen who runs the ball often, is headed to free agency having tossed just 11 career tds to 22 ints. Buffalo was thrilled with him as a player after signing him late in the 2019 season when they were in a pinch. He went on to earn an extension to stay for 2020. However his play the last two seasons hasn't inspired confidence.
22. Sean Mannion, is headed into his 7th season in the NFL after spending time as the backup to Jared Goff with the Rams for 4 years, and Kirk Cousins in Minnesota for 2 years. However despite throwing 74 passes and completing over 60% of his throws he has not thrown a single td passing put up 3 ints. He is not at all mobile and has simply bounced from one offense to another due to his knowledge of the system. He is a candidate for the 49ers, Rams, Jets, and Vikings. Basically any team that runs the Shanahan system.
That about sums up the unresteicted free agents but there are still interesting names on the restricted free agent list, or exclusive rights free agent list.
First on this list is Nick Mullens,in my eyes he is a high level backup with the upside to be a starter, in fact I believe he returns to San Francisco and challenges for the starting job whether they move on from Jimmy G or not. Mullens was an undrafted free agent just 3 years ago out of Southern Mississippi. He has played in 19 games completing 387 of 600 passes for 4,714 yards, 25 tds and 22 ints 7.9 yards per attempt. Proving he has the talent to play in this league he just needs to cut down on mistakes to become a starting level talent.
Josh Rosen was signed off of the Buccaneers practice squad by the 49ers making them his 4th team in just 3 seasons. He is an exclusive rights free agent and the 49ers lose nothing by keeping him around as competition or as a developmental prospect. He is still just 23 years old so he has time to learn to cut down on mistakes, and improve his accuracy but a below 55% completion rate, and 12 to 19 td to int ratio isn't doing him any favors even though everyone is aware the two teams he suited up for were messes.
Kyle Allen is headed into his 4th season. He spent his entire 3 year career under Ron Rivera, in 2018 he was signed as an undrafted free agent as an emergency QB behind Cam Newton, and Taylor Heineke. Both wound up getting injured paving the way for Allen to start and play well ultimately earning himself the number 2 role behind Newton which would prove to be important in 2019 when Newton suited up for just 3 games. Allen went on to start 13 games completing over 60% of his passes, for 3,322 yards, 17 tds and 16 ints. Rivera was fired after the season but quickly hired by the Washington Football Team, where he wasted very little time before trading for Kyle Allen to compete with Dwayne Haskins, and Alex Smith for the starting job. Ultimately Allen played in 4 games playing his best football yet completing just under 69% of his passes for 610 yards, 4 tds 1 int. He is an exclusive rights free agent and someone Rivera no doubt wants to retain.
Jake Rudock was once touted as a highly thought of backup qb. 5 years later he has managed to hold down the 3rd string role in Miami after beginning his career in Detroit. However despite the hype around him no team has given him the chance to be the top backup for long. He is likely a journeyman 3rd string qb at best in 2021.
Tim Boyle the Green Bay Packers 3rd string qb is headed toward free agency. He is just 26 years old with 3 years experience in the NFL. He stands 6'4 232 lbs prototypical size for an NFL qb and he will likely find another job based on that and the fact that he sat behind Rodgers learning under LaFluer and McCarthy. His lack of mobility might prove to be an issue but his size and strength equate to an NFL caliber arm.
We aren't done yet. I saved the best group for last the trade candidates this group couldn't be anymore tantalizing than it is.
The top prospect is Deshaun Watson of the Texans. Watson has become disenchanted with the team that drafted him and later handed him over $100 million on his second contract due to personnel and front office moves that weren't run by him after being told the franchise would give him transparency, something he hasn't had in the past. However they didn't uphold this bargain instead hiring a GM without talking to him at all. Watson would warrant multiple first round picks and possibly more to acquire as he should. He is a virtual can't miss qb at this point.
Carson Wentz might be floated in trade rumors after being benched this season for 2nd round pick Jalen Hurts. Wentz was said to be unhappy with the franchise but that was before they fired their coach. It remains to be seen if this former league MVP candidate gets moved or if the Eagles attempt to patch things up and move on. If he is moved Indianapolis makes too much sense and is likely where his value is highest. The Colts might be the only team willing to give up a first round pick. Especially being that Rivers retired, and Brissett is a free agent.
Gardner Minshew was a hit with the Naguars as a rookie so they gave him a chance in 2020 and it didnt pan out as they had hoped, or did it? The Jaguars secured the top pick after winning just 1 game leading some to believe Minshew might be on the move to a team interested in the mustache rocking maven who created a media frenzy complete with it's own name "Minshew Mania" might be coming to a town near you for the low low price of a 5th or 6th round pick. Minshew might stick around as a backup with the Jaguars.
Derek Carr has been rumored to be in the Jon Gruden dog house since day 1, last season he finally signed a qb who could step in as a starter if Carr got traded. Marcus Mariota is a former starter turned Carr's backup but he could be the reason the Raiders move on in 2021. Only time will tell. I believe the Raiders could get a 2nd round pick in return from the right team being that Carr is a career starter.
Jimmy Garrappolo has fallen out of favor in San Francisco but they may as well try and get something in return for him especially being that his former coach Bill Belicheck who didn't want to let him go in the first place needs a qb now. The Patriots would likely jump at the chance to acquire Garrappolo for a 4th or 5th round pick.
Nick Foles is still under contract for the Bears but with Mitch Trubisky having played well toward the end of his season Foles might be the next qb to get traded. He is pretty familiar with Nagy which may lead him to getting one last chance to be a bridge qb for Chicago but we shall see what the future holds.
Matthew Stafford is another name that has been tossed around in trade rumors, honestly this is something I hope happens. Stafford is one of those good guys you have to root for the perennial under dog who still plays through injury to start even though it's been for a bad team much of his career. He is a guy I feel would fit well in Denver with Pat Shurmur as his offensive coordinator, as well as built in weapons in Noah Fant, Courtland Sutton, Jerry Jeudy, Kj Hamler, Melvin Gordon, and Phillip Lindsay probably the most talent he would have ever been surrounded by.